Choose an Engagement Ring: the 2024 Guide

Ah yes! The engagement ring - no ordinary piece of jewellery. It holds tales of romance and whispers promises of commitment. But with so many styles and stones out there, how do you find 'the one'?

Embark on the journey to Choose an Engagement Ring: the 2024 Guide. You want that sparkle in her eyes as she sees it – just as bright as the diamond ring itself.

In this guide, we'll navigate through ethically sourced gemstones, and affordable options, without compromising style or charm. We'll discuss various metal choices impacting aesthetics and price while ensuring comfort by finding that ideal fit.

And we're not just sticking to traditional white diamonds. We're diving deeper into this fascinating world!

Table Of Contents:

The Ethical and Affordable Engagement Ring Journey

When it comes to popping the question, an engagement ring plays a crucial role. It's not just about picking any diamond engagement ring; it's about finding that perfect engagement ring that is ethically sourced, affordable, and speaks volumes about your love story.

Finding such a gem may sound daunting at first, but fear not. We have you covered on how to embark on this thrilling journey while prioritizing ethical sourcing and affordability.

Understanding Diamond Shapes and Sizes

To start with, let’s talk diamonds - the centre stone of most engagement rings. The shape of your diamond can greatly influence its overall appeal. From princess cut to oval or pear-shaped diamonds – each has its unique charm.

A popular choice for many are round brilliant cuts because they offer unparalleled brilliance (no pun intended). Yet others prefer more geometric shapes like emerald or Asscher cuts which exude vintage elegance.

GIA Encyclopedia, offers comprehensive information on different diamond shapes if you wish to explore deeper into this topic.

Moving onto sizes now - remember that bigger isn’t always better when buying an engagement ring online or from a store. While larger diamonds make for striking pieces, they also come with hefty price tags due their carat weight (diamond's carat being one of the 4C’s used to determine a diamond’s value).

Exploring Different Ring Styles

The style of your set significantly contributes towards creating an impact too. A solitaire setting beautifully highlights the centre stone but lacks extra sparkle offered by side stones in three-stone settings or halo designs where smaller accenting diamonds surround the main gemstone giving an illusion of a larger diamond.

Ring styles can also reflect personal preferences and tastes. Some people love the timeless elegance of vintage designs while others lean towards modern minimalist looks.

Guthrie Jewellery, has an extensive collection showcasing different engagement ring styles that could help you in your search for the perfect ring.

Key Takeaway: 

Choosing the perfect engagement ring is an exciting journey that goes beyond just picking a diamond. It's about finding a gem that reflects your love story, while being ethically sourced and affordable. Understanding diamond shapes, sizes, and styles plays a crucial role in this process. Remember: size isn't always everything; it's about choosing what resonates with you both.

Choosing the Right Metal for Your Ring

When you're on the hunt for the ideal engagement ring, picking the right metal is equally as important as choosing your centre stone. Each metal type contributes a distinctive factor to the overall aesthetics and cost of the engagement ring.

White Gold Engagement Rings

The allure of white gold engagement rings lies in their sleek modern look. They are chic and versatile, complementing diamonds or coloured stones alike with grace and sophistication.

This increasingly popular choice combines pure gold with other white metals like palladium or nickel to create its signature color. The final touch comes from rhodium plating which gives it a mirror-like finish, enhancing any diamond's clarity by providing an ideal backdrop.

You might wonder about maintenance - but don't worry. Over time, this coating may wear off, revealing a yellowish hue underneath due to the natural color of gold itself. But regular re-plating can keep your white gold ring looking shiny and new.

Rose Gold Engagement Rings

Rose gold, on the other hand, carries a romantic aura around it with its warm blush tones reminding one of love letters written during the Middle Ages. A blend of pure gold with copper alloy creates this charming hue that flatters all skin tones while offering more durability than yellow or white gold options because copper is tough stuff.

Another reason rose gold has become so popular lately? It works wonderfully well when paired with different types of stones - be they classic diamonds, vibrant colored diamonds, or even unique alternatives like opals and sapphires. So, if you're aiming for a ring set that stands out from the crowd - rose gold might be your ideal pick.

Keep in mind, if you're picking between white and rose gold, think about possible metal allergies. White gold contains nickel which can sometimes lead to skin reactions. On the other hand, rose gold uses copper - a material typically less likely to cause issues.

Key Takeaway: 

When hunting for the perfect engagement ring, consider your metal options. White gold rings are sleek and modern, enhancing diamonds with their mirror-like finish but require regular re-plating to maintain shine. Rose gold's romantic blush tones offer durability and work well with various stones - an ideal choice if you want a standout ring set.

Selecting the perfect engagement ring to fit your partner's finger can be a challenge, particularly if you are planning a surprise proposal and do not want to give away any clues. Especially if you're planning a surprise proposal and don't want to give away your intentions.

The last thing you want is for that perfect diamond engagement ring to slip off or squeeze too tight. So let’s break down how you can ensure a comfortable fit while keeping the element of surprise intact.

Secretly Measuring Your Partner's Finger

To keep everything under wraps, one method might be using a ring they already wear regularly on their left-hand ring finger. But remember: fingers swell in heat and shrink in cold weather, so try to choose an average-sized day when deciding this way.

If it's not possible to borrow one of their rings without arousing suspicion, then consider drawing around it on paper instead - just make sure it lies flat. Alternatively, we can send a free ring sizer if you enquire through our contact form.

Finding Out Discreetly from Friends or Family

You could ask friends or family members if they know your partner's size – someone may have bought them a ring before. It never hurts to gather more information.

Bear in mind though that even with all these stealthy techniques at play; some guesswork might still be involved as everyone has different hands and fingers which fluctuate over time due conditions like temperature changes and diet fluctuations.

Jeweller Assistance For Accurate Sizing

If secrecy isn’t paramount or after the question has been popped (and answered positively), go together with your partner to a professional jeweller. They have specialised tools and expertise to accurately determine ring size.

Some jewellers even offer resizing services, so if the fit isn't quite right initially, it can be adjusted later on. However, certain styles like tension set or eternity band rings may not allow for resizing due to their specific design elements.

Remember The Comfort Factor

Remember, it's crucial to find a ring that fits snugly but also provides comfort. The ring should slide on easily yet need a bit of effort to remove. This might be more challenging if your partner's knuckles are larger than usual.

Key Takeaway: 

Consider visiting the jeweller as a couple. This approach allows you to achieve the ideal fit, explore various styles, and creates a memorable experience. Keep in mind that the goal is to find a ring that symbolises your unique love story.

The Rise of Alternative Stones in Engagement Rings

Instead of diamonds, many couples are increasingly choosing alternative gemstones like rubies, emeralds, opals, and moissanite for their engagement rings. This shift is driven by a desire for individuality and self-expression. Additionally, some opt for these alternatives because they tend to be more budget-friendly compared to traditional diamond rings.

The Charm of Ruby Engagement Rings

Ruby engagement rings exude an allure that's hard to resist. Their vibrant red color symbolises love and passion, making them perfect for such a significant piece of jewellery.

These gemstones were held in high esteem by ancient cultures who believed they possessed magical powers. Today, ruby engagement rings still captivate with their stunning beauty and rich symbolism.

Apart from their enchanting aesthetic appeal, rubies rank nine on the Mohs scale (diamonds being ten), which means they're extremely durable - a practical consideration when choosing an everyday wear ring like your engagement one.

The Appeal of Moissanite Engagement Rings

If you haven't heard about moissanite yet - buckle up. This stone has been gaining popularity as a diamond alternative at warp speed thanks to its remarkable properties.

Moissanite, a naturally occurring silicon carbide first discovered inside meteor craters by scientist Henri Moisan in 1893 is almost as hard as diamonds but sparkles even more thanks to its higher refractive index.

Moissanite engagement rings are also much less expensive than diamond ones, allowing you to go for a bigger stone or a fancier setting without breaking the bank. This means they're not just beautiful but practical too.

The Enchantment of Emerald Engagement Rings

If green holds special appeal for you, consider an emerald as the ideal choice for your engagement ring. The vivid hue of this gemstone symbolises renewal and hope, making it a fitting sentiment as you embark on the journey of married life. Emeralds, belonging to the beryl family, are renowned for their stunning green color, which has been cherished throughout history due to their exceptional beauty.

Key Takeaway: 

Emerald engagement rings, on the other hand, bring a touch of elegance and rarity with their stunning green hues. Each stone tells its own story, allowing couples to choose something that truly resonates with them.

Lab-Grown Diamonds - A Budget-Friendly

You're ready to pop the question, but you need that perfect engagement ring. However, with today's focus on ethical sourcing and affordability, a lab-grown diamond may be your answer.

Let's debunk a common myth: lab-grown diamonds are indeed genuine diamonds, possessing identical physical and chemical properties to natural counterparts. But what sets them apart? Here are three compelling reasons behind the rising popularity of these radiant gems for engagement rings.

Affordability of Lab-Grown Diamonds

If we're talking budget-friendly options without compromising on quality or size, then lab-grown diamonds top the list. According to Diamond Pro, they can be as much as 30% less expensive than their naturally mined counterparts.

This means the possibility of affording a larger carat diamond within your budget, allowing you to imagine sliding a remarkable 1-carat diamond onto your partner's finger during that enchanting marriage proposal. It also open doors for increased creativity when it comes to engagement ring style, offering choices like unique diamond settings or trendy coloured diamonds, departing from the traditional white hue.

Eco-Conscious Choice

In addition to being budget-friendly, opting for a lab-grown diamond demonstrates environmental consciousness by curbing environmentally harmful mining activities. This represents a win-win scenario, to say the least.

The process involves replicating nature’s method under controlled conditions in laboratories which leads to no displacement of land or wildlife—something not guaranteed with naturally mined stones. So by choosing this option you’re making sure love doesn’t cost us Earth.

Socially Responsible Selection

Lastly, lab-grown diamonds are a socially responsible choice. The diamond industry has been marred by issues like child labor and conflict funding.

Choosing a lab-grown diamond means you're backing an industry that values human rights and fair pay. You’re making sure your love symbol isn't tarnished with any dark history—a thought that would appeal to those who care deeply about ethics.

Key Takeaway: 

Lab-grown diamonds are a real, affordable choice for engagement rings that don't skimp on quality or size. They go beyond being budget-friendly; they also offer an eco-friendly and socially responsible alternative. Opting for these diamonds means endorsing ethical practices while guaranteeing that your love doesn't cost the Earth. 


Selecting the optimal engagement ring may appear daunting, but bear in mind that you have already commenced your voyage. By following our guide on How to Choose an Engagement Ring: the 2024 Guide, you're well on your way.

Diamonds or alternative stones? We explored them all! From ruby and moissanite engagement rings to lab-grown diamonds - there's a world of choice beyond traditional white diamonds.

We also dived into metal choices that impact aesthetics and price. Whether it's classic white gold or increasingly popular rose gold, let your decision reflect personal taste and style.

Remember, size does matter when it comes to ensuring comfort for that surprise proposal. A ring should not only needs to look good but feel right too!

Back to blog